Menu
17/11/2009
Death Penalty Advocated By Former Judge
A senior retired judge has called for the death penalty to be reinstated in certain cases.
Mr Justice Richard Johnson, the former High Court president, said in an interview yesterday that the death penalty for certain kinds of murder, for example those committed during armed robberies, should be revisited.
He said: "I am not totally in favour of it. But it should be revisited. It would have to be for specific offences."
“The government should look at it, then if the people want it, they should have it.”
The Irish Council for Civil Liberties responded today and denounced the remarks as "deeply misguided and frivolous".
Mark Kelly of the council said that the death penalty was unlawful in every European Union and every Council of Europe state. If Ireland wished to reintroduce the death penalty, it could do so only at the cost of renouncing its membership of the European Union and the Council of Europe.
Meanwhile, Labour's spokesperson on Europe and Human Rights, Joe Costello, said that every government had a duty to protect the life of its citizens.
"It is wrong for a government to take the life of a citizen because that citizen may have taken the life of another citizen. The death penalty is brutal, it gives rise to irreversible miscarriages of justice and there is no evidence that it is an effective deterrent.
"It would be foolish to re-open the debate on the death penalty considering the proximity of constitutional and legislative decisions by the Irish people to abolish it.
Mr Costello said that conversely, as Ireland had a strong record on human rights it should be to the forefront in seeking abolition of the death penalty globally.
(DW/KMcA)
Mr Justice Richard Johnson, the former High Court president, said in an interview yesterday that the death penalty for certain kinds of murder, for example those committed during armed robberies, should be revisited.
He said: "I am not totally in favour of it. But it should be revisited. It would have to be for specific offences."
“The government should look at it, then if the people want it, they should have it.”
The Irish Council for Civil Liberties responded today and denounced the remarks as "deeply misguided and frivolous".
Mark Kelly of the council said that the death penalty was unlawful in every European Union and every Council of Europe state. If Ireland wished to reintroduce the death penalty, it could do so only at the cost of renouncing its membership of the European Union and the Council of Europe.
Meanwhile, Labour's spokesperson on Europe and Human Rights, Joe Costello, said that every government had a duty to protect the life of its citizens.
"It is wrong for a government to take the life of a citizen because that citizen may have taken the life of another citizen. The death penalty is brutal, it gives rise to irreversible miscarriages of justice and there is no evidence that it is an effective deterrent.
"It would be foolish to re-open the debate on the death penalty considering the proximity of constitutional and legislative decisions by the Irish people to abolish it.
Mr Costello said that conversely, as Ireland had a strong record on human rights it should be to the forefront in seeking abolition of the death penalty globally.
(DW/KMcA)
Related Irish News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
08 April 2024
Over 660 Motorists Found Speeding Over Easter Bank Holidays
More than 660 motorists were caught breaking the speed limit across the Causeway Coast and Glens during the Easter bank holiday weekend – an increase of 22% from 2022. Chief Inspector Sinead McIldowney said: "The Safety Camera Vans were deployed at various locations across the North Coast and the increase in these detections is a worrying trend.
Over 660 Motorists Found Speeding Over Easter Bank Holidays
More than 660 motorists were caught breaking the speed limit across the Causeway Coast and Glens during the Easter bank holiday weekend – an increase of 22% from 2022. Chief Inspector Sinead McIldowney said: "The Safety Camera Vans were deployed at various locations across the North Coast and the increase in these detections is a worrying trend.
08 May 2019
On-Duty Firefighter Arrested On Suspicion Of Drink Driving
A fireman has been arrested on suspicion of drink driving while on duty behind the wheel of a fire engine. The man was driving a fire truck on the Callan Road, Kilkenny over the weekend and approached a checkpoint. It is believed he was returning from an emergency incident and failed a breath test. He was issued a fixed charged penalty notice.
On-Duty Firefighter Arrested On Suspicion Of Drink Driving
A fireman has been arrested on suspicion of drink driving while on duty behind the wheel of a fire engine. The man was driving a fire truck on the Callan Road, Kilkenny over the weekend and approached a checkpoint. It is believed he was returning from an emergency incident and failed a breath test. He was issued a fixed charged penalty notice.
08 December 2014
Learner Drivers Could Face Penalty Points
New penalty point offences are to take effect from today (8 December), the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport, Paschal Donohoe TD, has confirmed. Under the new legislation, penalty points will include for a number of road offenses, while a further 14 offences will bring penalty points for the first time.
Learner Drivers Could Face Penalty Points
New penalty point offences are to take effect from today (8 December), the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport, Paschal Donohoe TD, has confirmed. Under the new legislation, penalty points will include for a number of road offenses, while a further 14 offences will bring penalty points for the first time.
19 March 2013
Japanese Court Finds 19-Year-Old Guilty Of Nicola Furlong Murder
19-year-old American musician Richard Hinds has been found guilty and sentenced to 10 years in jail at Tokyo District Court for strangling Irish exchange student Nicola Furlong.
Japanese Court Finds 19-Year-Old Guilty Of Nicola Furlong Murder
19-year-old American musician Richard Hinds has been found guilty and sentenced to 10 years in jail at Tokyo District Court for strangling Irish exchange student Nicola Furlong.
13 March 2013
Flanagan Admits Having Penalty Points Cancelled
The Dáil has heard an admission from Independent TD Luke ‘Ming’ Flanagan that penalties point he was to receive for driving offence were cancelled, on two separate occasions. In both incidents, Flanagan was stopped by garda for using a mobile phone while driving.
Flanagan Admits Having Penalty Points Cancelled
The Dáil has heard an admission from Independent TD Luke ‘Ming’ Flanagan that penalties point he was to receive for driving offence were cancelled, on two separate occasions. In both incidents, Flanagan was stopped by garda for using a mobile phone while driving.
-
Ireland WeatherToday:Very windy with persistent and occasionally heavy rain at first, becoming drier with the wind easing towards midday. Mainly dry with bright spells increasing during the afternoon. Milder than of late. Maximum temperature 14 °C.Tonight:Cloudy with clear spells, mainly dry evening becoming windy with rain at times from late evening. Turning drier with clear spells towards morning. Milder than of late. Minimum temperature 2 °C.
