Menu
09/02/2010
Abuse Victims Write To Pope
Surviving victims of clerical sexual abuse have written an open letter to Pope Benedict XVI regarding the Ryan and Murphy Report revelations.
The letter from victims group One in Four, and signed by abuse survivors Marie Collins, Maeve Lewis and Andrew Madden, comes just as Irish bishops prepare to meet the Pontiff in the Vatican next week.
The letter contains a number of severe criticisms, including that the group had found it incomprehensible the Vatican and the Papal Nuncio had hidden behind diplomatic protocols to avoid cooperating with the Murphy Commission.
The Papal Nuncio – who is the Vatican's representative in Ireland - had rejected accusations of non-cooperation with the Murphy investigations by claiming that information requests had been responded to through diplomatic channels.
The letter said: "The distress, anger and frustration experienced by survivors since the publication of the Report of the Commission of Investigation into Sexual Abuse in the Archdiocese of Dublin (the Murphy Report) is enormous. Many who have suffered throughout their lives from the impact of sexual abuse by priests in childhood now realise, having read the Report, that their pain and suffering could have been avoided if senior churchmen and the civil authorities had acted properly in response to complaints received from earlier victims.
"Survivors find in incomprehensible that the Vatican and your representative in Ireland, the Papal Nuncio, saw fit to hide behind diplomatic protocols to avoid co-operating with the Murphy Commission."
Yesterday, representatives of the bishops met leaders of four survivors' groups as part of ongoing consultations and said they would relay the survivors' concerns to the Pope.
The letter also called for the Pope to instruct Irish bishops to comply fully with child protection guidelines, including the mandatory reporting of all concerns or complaints to authorities.
The letter went on to urged the Pope to remove Bishop Martin Drennan who, they say, still refuses to accept any responsibility for his part in supporting a culture of cover-up during his time in the Dublin Archdiocese.
Separately, it has been reported that survivors will also ask the Pope for a €1bn compensation package, and request a meeting during his visit to England in September.
(DW/BMcC)
The letter from victims group One in Four, and signed by abuse survivors Marie Collins, Maeve Lewis and Andrew Madden, comes just as Irish bishops prepare to meet the Pontiff in the Vatican next week.
The letter contains a number of severe criticisms, including that the group had found it incomprehensible the Vatican and the Papal Nuncio had hidden behind diplomatic protocols to avoid cooperating with the Murphy Commission.
The Papal Nuncio – who is the Vatican's representative in Ireland - had rejected accusations of non-cooperation with the Murphy investigations by claiming that information requests had been responded to through diplomatic channels.
The letter said: "The distress, anger and frustration experienced by survivors since the publication of the Report of the Commission of Investigation into Sexual Abuse in the Archdiocese of Dublin (the Murphy Report) is enormous. Many who have suffered throughout their lives from the impact of sexual abuse by priests in childhood now realise, having read the Report, that their pain and suffering could have been avoided if senior churchmen and the civil authorities had acted properly in response to complaints received from earlier victims.
"Survivors find in incomprehensible that the Vatican and your representative in Ireland, the Papal Nuncio, saw fit to hide behind diplomatic protocols to avoid co-operating with the Murphy Commission."
Yesterday, representatives of the bishops met leaders of four survivors' groups as part of ongoing consultations and said they would relay the survivors' concerns to the Pope.
The letter also called for the Pope to instruct Irish bishops to comply fully with child protection guidelines, including the mandatory reporting of all concerns or complaints to authorities.
The letter went on to urged the Pope to remove Bishop Martin Drennan who, they say, still refuses to accept any responsibility for his part in supporting a culture of cover-up during his time in the Dublin Archdiocese.
Separately, it has been reported that survivors will also ask the Pope for a €1bn compensation package, and request a meeting during his visit to England in September.
(DW/BMcC)
Related Irish News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
07 December 2009
Bishop Murray Expected To Resign
An Irish Bishop, whose failures in regard to clerical sex abuse were described as "inexcusable" in the recent Murphy report, is expected to resign during a visit to Rome today.
Bishop Murray Expected To Resign
An Irish Bishop, whose failures in regard to clerical sex abuse were described as "inexcusable" in the recent Murphy report, is expected to resign during a visit to Rome today.
22 March 2010
Bishop Seeks 'Renewal' Of Church
Just days after Pope Benedict XVI apologised to victims of child sex abuse by Catholic priests in Ireland, an Irish bishop has sought "accountability" from the State's inquiry into clerical child sex abuse in Ireland.
Bishop Seeks 'Renewal' Of Church
Just days after Pope Benedict XVI apologised to victims of child sex abuse by Catholic priests in Ireland, an Irish bishop has sought "accountability" from the State's inquiry into clerical child sex abuse in Ireland.
11 December 2009
Pope Shares 'Shame' Felt By Irish
After a meeting with Ireland's most influential clergy today, Pope Benedict has said he shared the "shame" felt by the Irish people over the findings of the Murphy Report into clerical abuse. The statement followed a meeting with Primate of All Ireland Cardinal Seán Brady along with Archbishop of Dublin Diarmuid Martin.
Pope Shares 'Shame' Felt By Irish
After a meeting with Ireland's most influential clergy today, Pope Benedict has said he shared the "shame" felt by the Irish people over the findings of the Murphy Report into clerical abuse. The statement followed a meeting with Primate of All Ireland Cardinal Seán Brady along with Archbishop of Dublin Diarmuid Martin.
20 March 2012
Vatican To Publish Child Abuse Report
A Vatican report of the child abuse crisis in the Catholic Church is to be published in Rome today. Teams of Vatican-appointed foreign church leaders have compiled the report following visits to Ireland.
Vatican To Publish Child Abuse Report
A Vatican report of the child abuse crisis in the Catholic Church is to be published in Rome today. Teams of Vatican-appointed foreign church leaders have compiled the report following visits to Ireland.
16 February 2010
TD Slams Vatican Representative
A Fine Gael TD has slammed the Papal Nuncio for his failure to cooperate with the Murphy reports and for his refusal to answer questions at a joint Oireachtas committee.
TD Slams Vatican Representative
A Fine Gael TD has slammed the Papal Nuncio for his failure to cooperate with the Murphy reports and for his refusal to answer questions at a joint Oireachtas committee.
-
Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:West to northwest gale force winds, severe along the north coast, will continue overnight. Frequent showers persist, merging into longer periods of rain at times and turning wintry. Minimum temperature 1 °C.
