22/06/2010

Gov Withdraws Gender Case Appeal

The Irish Government has withdrawn its appeal against a High Court ruling that found Ireland was in breach of the European Convention of Human Rights.

The Government had been involved in 13-year legal battle brought by Dr Lydia Foy against the State, who was registered as male at birth and fought for legal recognition to live as a woman.

The State had denied Dr Foy's attempt to change her birth certificate, but this was overruled by the High Court who said the Government's refusal had not been compatible with European rights. The Government then launched an appeal against the ruling, but this week withdrew their action.

The Labour LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender) has welcomed the decision to drop the High Court appeal. Speaking this afternoon after the announcement Labour LGBT Co-Chairs Niamh Hayes and Paul McConnell in a joint statement said: "We are delighted with this news for Dr Lydia Foy, who has been forced to go through an extended legal battle in order to achieve this victory. We are also delighted for the many other transgendered people in Ireland that this will affect.

“The Labour Party included a commitment to introduce a Gender Recognition Bill in our 2007 election manifesto, and re-affirmed our policy in this area at Party Conference in April. The impetus is now clearly on the Minister for Social Protection to legislate without delay in this area.”

The Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL) also welcomed the decision. ICCL Director Mr. Mark Kelly said: "It was unconscionable that the Government saw it fit in 2007 to launch an appeal to the Supreme Court in this case, and in so doing further delay the granting of rights to which Dr Foy was fully entitled under the European Convention on Human Rights."

(DW)




Related Irish News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

04 July 2014
National Oversight And Audit Commission Established
The Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government, Mr Phil Hogan has announced the establishment of the National oversight and Audit Commission, (NoAC), for the local government sector.
05 June 2014
Govt Urged To Reopen 'Hooded Men' Case
The government has been urged to reverse the decision of its Attorney General and appeal to the European Court of Human Rights for the reopening of the 1970s 'Hooded Men' case, which alleges torture by the British government.
14 October 2011
Finucanes Continue Inquiry Campaign
The Finucane family has announced that they will continue their campaign to get an independent inquiry into the murder of solicitor Pat Finucane, this time with Irish government support and despite the British government saying they could only offer a review.
30 January 2014
Lufthansa Staff Appeal To Government
The Government has been asked to help protect the viability of the Lufthansa plant in Rathcoole, Co Dublin. A small group of the 400 workers, due to lose their jobs in the coming weeks, held a protest outside Leinster House before handing a letter in to the Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation.
19 March 2013
Report Highlights Lenient Sentencing
Judges in manslaughter cases tend to be more lenient if drink and drugs are involved, even though intoxication is not a defence in law or a mitigating factor, a new report on sentencing has found that A report, carried out by the Irish Sentencing Information System, analysed sentences in manslaughter cases over five years between 2007 and 2012.