07/08/2009

Referendum Sought Over Civil Appeal Court

A high-level judicial committee is calling for a referendum to establish a full-time Court of Appeal.

At present the Supreme Court deals with all civil appeals from the High Court.

The average waiting-time for an appeal to the Supreme Court has increased from four to 30 months in the past five years.

The judicial committee said the backlog is impeding the Supreme Court and a referendum to establish a new Court of Appeal is necessary to address the problem.

The committee is to call for the referendum this morning. The working group, led by Supreme Court judge Mrs Justice Susan Denham, has warned that delays in the Supreme Court could harm parents and children embroiled in family law proceedings.

Many other countries, such as the UK and America, use an intermediate court to prevent automatic referrals coming from the High Court to the Supreme Court on appeal.

The Supreme Court currently hears a range of cases, which are commonly heard by an intermediate court in other countries and this has been causing a build up in cases.

Supreme Court Judge Mrs Justice Susan Denham said: "Delays create confusion and costs and are bad for business. This situation poses serious problems for the Irish legal system and for irish society as a whole."

(DW/BMcc)

Related Irish News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

27 September 2013
Judge Says Supreme Court Backlog 'Unsustainable'
Ahead of the upcoming referendum on a Court of Appeal, Cheif Justice Susan Denham has said that the current Supreme Court backlog of four years is an "unsustainable situation". According to the Irish Time, Judge Denham also highlights that the Supreme Court is one of the "busiest courts of its kind in the world".
05 March 2010
Supreme Court Removes Fleming's Protection
The future of a Co Cork building company is under thread after the Supreme Court overruled a High Court decision to approve a survival plan for the firm. The Fleming Group has collective debts of €1bn. Last year, the High Court appointed an examiner to attempt to devise a plan to secure the future of the beleaguered company.
15 September 2009
Judge To Rule Again On Zoe Protection
Eamon Carroll's troubled property group Zoe is to go back to the High Court today to find out if it will be allowed a fourth bid to gain court protection. Mr Justice Frank Clarke last week again rejected an application from the heavily indebted group for the appointment of an examiner to seven of the Zoe companies.
07 March 2016
Supreme Court Judge Adrian Hardiman Dies
Supreme Court judge Adrian Hardiman has died suddenly at his home in Dublin. Taoiseach Enda Kenny said he was shocked to hear the news of his death. He said: "Adrian had a long and illustrious legal career and was one of the great minds of our time.
24 April 2015
Fianna Fáil Welcomes Supreme Court Decision On Children's Referendum
Fianna Fáil has welcomed the Supreme Court decision to uphold the results of the Children's Referendum. The referendum was held in November 2012, and introduced two key measures around children's rights, including state intervention in exceptional circumstances, and focusing on the best interests of the child in any legal proceeding.